How Much Unknown Harm Can Our Certainty Cause?
Weekly reflections from Pure Pawsitivity | Week 15
What if the thing we're absolutely certain about is the very thing we haven't fully understood?
What I Learned This Week
In 2020, I made one of the best decisions of my adult life.
I got off social media.
COVID, politics, constant arguing. Apparently, overnight, everybody had become an expert in infectious diseases, economics, constitutional law, and human psychology all at once.
Impressive, really.
Six years later, I'm still happily disconnected.
But my wife Edan occasionally reads me something she finds interesting.
This week, it was a local Facebook discussion about bringing dogs to public events.
A reasonable topic! Crowds, heat, noise, irresponsible owners. There's plenty worth discussing.
But somebody suggested allowing only "serious service animals."
Serious service animals?
Apparently, Rosa and Carlito missed the auditions.
Then came the comments.
One person insisted service dogs don't bark. Another suggested they're only for people who are blind or experience seizures.
And then:
"Your dog is NOT your child."
I understand that dogs and children are different.
But who's reading those words?
Someone who's experienced infertility? Lost a child? Built a family that looks different from yours?
I don't know these commenters. Some may have perfectly legitimate concerns.
But the certainty was astonishing.
Everybody was talking. I wondered if anybody was listening.
The timing was especially strange because I'd just given my Week 14 presentation about the confrontations Edan and I have experienced with our Chihuahua service dogs.
And now I was hearing those same assumptions from people in my own community.
I could feel myself getting worked up.
Which got me thinking about something seemingly unrelated.
The Great Wall of China.
Yep. Facebook arguments and ancient Chinese architecture.
Stay with me.
Some walls protect us. Others surround beliefs we've never really examined.
How often do we build walls around what we believe without knowing what's on the other side?
Watch This Week's Presentation
How Much Unknown Harm Can Our Certainty Cause? | Pawsitivity Presentation #15
This week, I'm exploring certainty, the harm our assumptions can cause, and what my Chihuahua Carlito taught me about asking better questions.
WATCH PAWSITIVITY PRESENTATION #15
The Animal in Front of Me
I've been playing with a little framework called SHARCS.
Sharks with a C. Obviously.
It reminds me of six things we humans seem to need:
S: Seen
H: Heard
A: Agency
R: Respected
C: Connected
S: Safe
It's my own little framework, something I'm exploring to help me consider what might be happening beneath someone's behavior.
And our animals have been teaching us to do that for years.
When Edan and I first started caring for Carlito, we had a serious problem.
He wouldn't eat.
He wasn't occasionally skipping meals. He was losing weight.
At one point, he was down to around three pounds. You could see his ribs.
We were terrified.
But we thought we knew what to do.
Find the best kibble.
We tried different brands, proteins, and formulas. I remember spending something like $90 on a ten-pound bag!
And Carlito still wouldn't eat.
We assumed he was incredibly picky.
Until we started asking different questions.
What if the problem wasn't Carlito? What if our understanding of his options was incomplete?
We hadn't even considered fresh, whole-food feeding options because we didn't know about them.
Eventually, we discovered other approaches, including fresh and raw foods.
I can't tell you exactly why Carlito resisted his earlier food. Smell? Taste? Texture? Something he'd learned?
I don't know.
But I can tell you what happened when we changed our approach.
Today, Carlito weighs almost six healthy pounds.
And when it's time for dinner?
That little guy dances!
The same Chihuahua we once struggled desperately to feed now dances when his food is being prepared.
We genuinely believed we were making the best choices available.
But our certainty kept us searching inside a box we didn't even know existed.
And Carlito was living with the consequences.
That experience changed our lives.
It's part of why Pure Pawsitivity exists.
The Moment I Caught Myself
Later that morning, I was sitting in an accessible parking space here in Fountain Hills.
I have a disability placard because of significant lower-back problems.
But I look relatively young and healthy.
And I've been confronted about using accessible parking before.
So when I noticed some older people looking in my direction, my mind immediately started working.
Here we go again.
They're probably wondering why I'm parked here.
They probably think I don't belong.
Maybe they're about to confront me.
But then something happened.
I caught myself.
Those people hadn't said anything.
I didn't know what they were thinking.
Maybe they were judging me.
Maybe they were looking at my truck.
Maybe they weren't thinking about me at all.
And suddenly, I realized something hilarious.
Holy shit. I'm making assumptions about their assumptions.
I'd spent the entire morning frustrated by people making judgments without enough information.
And here I was doing the exact same thing.
Well, that's embarrassing.
But also incredibly useful.
Because I noticed it before acting on it.
And suddenly, SHARCS became even more interesting.
Maybe somebody in that Facebook discussion was trying to feel safe.
Maybe someone else felt dismissed or disrespected.
Maybe those people in the parking lot were simply enjoying their morning.
I didn't know.
And that is the point.
Weekly Thought
Sometimes our certainty that we're doing the right thing can cause harm we never intended.
While researching this presentation, I came across studies that added another layer.
UC Davis researchers examined how people interpret dogs' reactions to household sounds. Some behaviors associated with fear or distress were perceived as amusing.
Researchers at Yale also found that social feedback can reinforce expressions of moral outrage online.
Both got me thinking about how easily our interpretations can become reinforced without necessarily becoming more accurate.
What if everybody agreeing with you doesn't actually mean you're right?
I can love Carlito and still misunderstand what he needs.
I can feel threatened by strangers and still be wrong about what they're thinking.
And I can build walls around my beliefs without realizing how much I haven't explored.
Curious About the Research?
1. Are We Misunderstanding Our Dogs?
UC Davis researchers found that some owners underestimated their dogs' fearfulness in response to common household noises. In online videos, people sometimes laughed at behaviors that could indicate genuine distress.
2. Can Social Media Reward Our Outrage?
Yale researchers found that positive feedback, including likes and shares, can reinforce expressions of moral outrage online.
Two very different studies. One fascinating question: How often does our confidence exceed our understanding?
Keep Exploring
Here's something I'm practicing this week.
The next time somebody does something that frustrates or confuses me, I'm going to notice the story my mind starts telling.
And before deciding I understand what's happening, I'll ask:
What do I actually know?
And what might I be missing?
Maybe one of those SHARCS needs is involved.
Maybe there's another explanation entirely.
I can maintain my boundaries without assuming my first interpretation is complete.
And I can remain willing to learn.
I keep thinking about Carlito dancing for his dinner.
That little dog helped us discover questions we didn't even know to ask.
And apparently, he's still teaching me.
Better Questions Create Better Choices.
Good Things Are Worth Sharing!
Know somebody who might appreciate this perspective?
Maybe someone who loves their animals, enjoys questioning their own assumptions, or occasionally finds themselves arguing with strangers on the internet.
We've all got something to practice.
If this week's reflection made you think, laugh, or consider something differently, feel free to pass it along.
SHARE PAWSITIVITY IN PRACTICE →
Pure Pawsitivity™
Learning in public by paying attention to the animal in front of us.
0 comments
Not done learning?
-
How Much Unknown Harm Can Our Certainty Cause?
How much harm can our certainty cause when we don't realize what we're missing? This week, a Facebook argument about service dogs, Carlito's struggles with food, and an unexpected realization in a parking lot challenged me to question my own assumptions. Sometimes the most important discovery is recognizing what we don't know.
-
How Much Do We Really Understand About Service Dogs?
What happens when the very animals helping you navigate a disability become the reason people challenge your right to enter a restaurant? This week, I'm sharing what Rosa and Carlito have taught me about service dogs, invisible disabilities, misplaced confidence, and the surprising difference a little understanding can make.
-
What Does It Really Mean to Have the Will to Do Something?
What does it really mean to have the will to do something? This week, a conversation with Daisy about her dog Moab, a little ancient Stoic philosophy, and an unexpected connection to the word PAW helped me rethink determination, flexibility, and what it means to keep choosing when things don't go as planned.