How Much Do We Really Understand About Service Dogs?
Weekly reflections from Pure Pawsitivity | Week 14
A person doesn't have to look disabled for their disability to be real.
What I Learned This Week
My wife Edan and I each spent over 15 years working in the restaurant industry.
We understand restaurants. We understand employees trying to do their jobs, keeping things clean, looking after customers, and managing a building full of hungry people.
But these days, I sometimes avoid restaurants altogether.
Especially ones I've never visited before.
And the reason might surprise you.
Our two Chihuahuas, Rosa and Carlito, are service dogs.
Yes, Chihuahuas.
And yes, two of them.
We also use a stroller because I have significant lower-back problems that make carrying them increasingly difficult.
Apparently, two Chihuahuas in a stroller are enough to short-circuit somebody's entire understanding of disability law.
Here's where things get interesting.
Edan and I had been visiting one particular restaurant for about 20 years.
Twenty freaking years!
The employees knew us. The manager knew us. Rosa and Carlito had probably been there over a hundred times.
Then one day, I walked in with their stroller.
The manager immediately stopped me.
He insisted they couldn't be service dogs, told me the stroller wasn't allowed, and asked me to leave.
I tried explaining, but he wasn't interested.
And the experience triggered something in me so intensely that I began shaking uncontrollably.
I couldn't even continue the conversation.
Edan stayed behind and tried to explain, but eventually we left.
We haven't been back.
Twenty years of being customers, and one confrontation changed everything.
That experience got me thinking about how quickly our assumptions can become conclusions.
And how much those conclusions can affect somebody else's life.
Watch This Week's Presentation
How Much Do We Really Understand About Service Dogs? | Pawsitivity Presentation #14
This week, I'm sharing some personal experiences with Rosa and Carlito, exploring some surprising details about service dog laws, and asking what happens when someone else's certainty affects our ability to participate in everyday life.
[WATCH PAWSITIVITY PRESENTATION #14]
The Animal in Front of Me
Here's something that surprises a lot of people.
Under the Americans with Disabilities Act, a person can have more than one service dog when each dog is individually trained to perform disability-related work or tasks.
There's also no federal requirement that a service dog be a particular breed or size.
And a person doesn't have to look disabled for their disability to be real.
But when people see two little Chihuahuas, they sometimes decide they already know everything about our situation.
They've observed us for approximately seven seconds, haven't asked a question, and somehow gathered enough evidence to present their case to the Supreme Court.
It's almost impressive.
And this raises another question.
How often do we confuse confidence with knowledge?
Sometimes the people most determined to enforce the rules are the people who haven't actually read them.
For example, did you know businesses generally have only two questions they're allowed to ask when a dog's service animal status isn't obvious?
-
Is the dog a service animal required because of a disability?
-
What work or task has the dog been trained to perform?
They cannot demand that someone disclose their diagnosis, produce medical documentation, or have the dog demonstrate its trained task.
And here's another one that surprises people.
The ADA doesn't require service dogs to have certifications, registrations, identification cards, or special vests.
Yet people purchase these things believing they're necessary, while some businesses demand them believing they're required.
We have actually purchased cards, obtained letters from doctors, and used identification patches ourselves.
After enough confrontations, you start looking for ways to make the next one easier.
Even when the paperwork isn't legally required.
Another misconception is that a service dog must behave perfectly every second of its life.
No mistakes. No distractions. No barking.
Really?
One bark and the dog immediately loses its credentials?
Does Carlito have to turn in his badge?
Is there a little Chihuahua unemployment office I don't know about?
The Department of Justice explains that a single bark doesn't automatically mean a service dog is out of control. Repeated uncontrolled barking can be grounds for removal, and handlers remain responsible for their dogs' behavior.
A service dog is still a living, breathing animal.
And that distinction matters.
The stroller question is particularly interesting to me because federal guidance generally describes service dogs as being on the floor or carried, but doesn't clearly resolve every situation involving a disabled handler using a stroller.
I'd actually like more specific guidance from the Department of Justice.
Because I don't think handlers or businesses should have to guess.
And I think understanding the circumstances before making a judgment would help everybody.
A Different Kind of Invisible Disability
With Veterans Day approaching, there's something else I wanted to share.
I originally began using service dogs because of a PTSD-related condition connected to my military service.
And I want to say something directly to other veterans.
You don't have to have served in combat for something that happened during military service to affect the rest of your life.
You don't have to have been shot at or blown up.
I've known people who struggled because their service didn't look the way they thought it was supposed to.
I've lost friends to suicide.
I can't pretend to know everything that led them there, but I've experienced how deeply shame, judgment, and the feeling of not being enough can affect someone.
You served. Your experience matters. And you don't have to prove that you suffered enough for it to count.
Now, here's something I never imagined would happen.
Rosa and Carlito help me navigate situations related to PTSD.
But after years of being confronted, questioned, yelled at, and sometimes denied access because of them, I started anticipating those confrontations before they even happened.
Before entering an unfamiliar restaurant, I'm already wondering:
Will somebody stop us?
Will they demand paperwork?
Will someone decide our dogs aren't legitimate?
Will I have to explain myself again?
Eventually, I began avoiding those situations.
And I still do.
Think about that.
The way people have treated me for having service dogs has created additional experiences that trigger the very condition those dogs help me manage.
That's a pretty strange outcome for something intended to make life more accessible.
Weekly Thought
Having the legal right to do something and being able to comfortably exercise that right are two very different experiences.
I remember another encounter from years ago.
Edan and I had tickets to a professional golf tournament in Phoenix.
We arrived with Rosa, who was our only service dog at the time.
At the entrance, a security guard started giving us a hard time.
He was yelling and mocking us, eventually shouting across the parking lot:
"Ain't no poochie woochie getting on my course!"
Poochie woochie?
Are we enforcing disability law or auditioning for a children's television show?
Eventually, we made it onto the course.
And we had a wonderful day.
One of my favorite moments happened when legendary golfer Bernhard Langer walked past us.
He stopped, smiled at little Rosa in my arms, and said something like, "Oh, cute doggy!"
His whole group paused for this tiny Chihuahua.
Same dog.
Same day.
Two completely different reactions.
And that's what continues to fascinate me.
The overwhelming majority of our experiences with Rosa and Carlito have been wonderful.
We've met incredible people at restaurants, concerts, sporting events, and just about everywhere you can imagine.
Sometimes employees ask the appropriate questions.
Sometimes they don't need to ask anything.
They simply treat us with respect, and we enjoy our day.
But here's the difficult part.
You can have a hundred wonderful encounters, and one terrible encounter can change how you experience the next hundred.
I know most people mean well.
That knowledge doesn't make the anticipation disappear.
When we're somewhere unfamiliar, I'm monitoring the dogs, watching their behavior, and making sure they're comfortable.
That's my responsibility as their handler.
But I'm also watching everybody else.
Wondering whether somebody is staring.
Whether someone is about to say something.
Whether one little bark is going to become another confrontation.
Sometimes I'm doing all of that while everybody around me is having a perfectly ordinary afternoon.
And the people who treat us respectfully probably have no idea how much easier they've just made our day.
Keep Exploring
The Department of Justice provides free guidance explaining service dog rights and responsibilities under the ADA.
It's worth reading whether you're a business owner, employee, service dog handler, or simply someone who wants to understand the subject better.
Because businesses do have legitimate responsibilities involving safety, cleanliness, and customer experiences.
Handlers have responsibilities, too.
I'd love to see more businesses become examples of how to navigate these situations thoughtfully.
Edan and I have even been discussing ways Pure Pawsitivity might help through simple educational visits or short training sessions.
Imagine how many unnecessary confrontations could be prevented if everybody understood a few basic distinctions.
EXPLORE THE ADA'S OFFICIAL SERVICE ANIMAL GUIDANCE
And I'd encourage one more thing.
The next time you see an arrangement involving a person and an animal that doesn't make sense to you, consider what you might be missing.
You may be looking at something you've never encountered before.
You may be looking at an accommodation that helps somebody participate in the world.
And you might simply be looking at two little Chihuahuas trying to enjoy an afternoon with their humans.
I keep coming back to that restaurant where we spent 20 years.
I don't want someone punished.
I don't want to argue.
I don't want to participate in a constitutional law seminar before ordering some brisket.
I just want lunch.
And I'd love for the next person walking through that door with a service dog to have an easier experience than we did.
Maybe that begins with something as simple as asking a better question before deciding we already know the answer.
Keep Practicing With Us
If this helped you understand service dogs a little differently, that's enough.
Pawsitivity in Practice is where we share what we're learning each week through our animals, the shop, the podcast, the research, and the questions that follow us home.
Good Things Are Worth Sharing!
Know somebody who works in a restaurant, owns a business, lives with a disability, or simply loves animals?
This might be a good one to pass along.
A little understanding can make an enormous difference in somebody else's day.
SHARE PAWSITIVITY IN PRACTICE →
Pure Pawsitivity™
Learning in public by paying attention to the animal in front of us.
0 comments
Not done learning?
-
How Much Unknown Harm Can Our Certainty Cause?
How much harm can our certainty cause when we don't realize what we're missing? This week, a Facebook argument about service dogs, Carlito's struggles with food, and an unexpected realization in a parking lot challenged me to question my own assumptions. Sometimes the most important discovery is recognizing what we don't know.
-
How Much Do We Really Understand About Service Dogs?
What happens when the very animals helping you navigate a disability become the reason people challenge your right to enter a restaurant? This week, I'm sharing what Rosa and Carlito have taught me about service dogs, invisible disabilities, misplaced confidence, and the surprising difference a little understanding can make.
-
What Does It Really Mean to Have the Will to Do Something?
What does it really mean to have the will to do something? This week, a conversation with Daisy about her dog Moab, a little ancient Stoic philosophy, and an unexpected connection to the word PAW helped me rethink determination, flexibility, and what it means to keep choosing when things don't go as planned.